Login to Complete an Application or to Access Judging Panel
DESIGN AWARD JUDGING RULES & INSTRUCTIONS
Judges of the FSPA Design Awards are volunteers with experience building swimming pools. They remain anonymous to the entrants and in turn the projects remain anonymous to the judges. To facilitate the judging process, here is an outline of the judging criteria, definitions of these criteria, and a chart to facilitate the process and return of judgments.
The purpose of the awards is to:
- Simulate the installation of attractive pools, spas and backyard environments.
- Recognize and reward innovative design, planning, landscaping, and craftsmanship in the development of the swimming pool and spa environment.
- Expand industry exposure to the consumer public in a positive manner.
- Assist participants in publicizing their product by using this competition as a marketing tool.
- Observe trends in swimming pool and spa design and construction.
As stated in the application in reference to judging, “The project’s achievements will be considered as well as the quality of workmanship, soundness of design, beauty, functionality and client testimony. Attention will be given to the surrounding landscaped area with regard to how well it harmonizes with the installation.”
DEFINITIONS
Workmanship: No one is perfect, but do they strive for perfection? Look through all the photos and see how precise the work is, if it is done properly, and if it is done to meet all applicable codes.
Soundness of Design: Review the project plans to confirm the layout and build are set up for success. Does it meet codes and best practices? Was it designed thoughtfully to meet the client’s requests?
Beauty: Beauty is in the eye of the beholder... is the pool aesthetically pleasing while meeting the client’s wish list? Even if it doesn’t have all the bells and whistles, are colors and design beautiful?
Functionality: Is the project giving the client the use they are looking for? Can they swim laps while their toddler plays and their teen lounges? Will the equipment work efficiently for the project? Are safety requirements met?
Harmony: Does the project look good with the surrounding landscaping or the home? Do the colors, textures, and aesthetics form a cohesive and pleasant look? When you look at the photos, does it look like the pool was made for the space as a whole?
Achievements: This could be a difficulty the project encountered or a unique element that was incorporated. It could also be as simple as hitting timelines despite complications.